The
Thrilling Detective
Hall of Fame

An eye's career may span more than one decade. Likewise, an eye may make his or her first appearance and then not make much of an impact or hit their stride for several years. So, the following eyes are listed by the year of their first appearance, although their best may be years later. They're counted for their quality, entertainment value, reflection of their times, influence on the genre and whether I liked them or not.

By the way, this list is very much a work in progress...Feel free to contradict me, or vote for your own favourites, by contacting me. Eventually, I'll have a form to use right about here...

The Honorary Eyes
Historical and Literary Influences on the Genre

  • Sir Lancelot
    Slightly tarnished, but not afraid to continue searching for the dingus.

  • Robin Hood
    Ran his own agency, called his hard-boiled ops Merry Men.


  • François Eugène Vidocq
    History's first recorded private detective.

  • Natty "Hawkeye" Bumpo
    When a man's partner is killed...

  • Wyatt Earp
    Gun for hire cleans up a town, see Red Harvest.

  • Shane
    Gun for hire reluctantly cleans up a town, see Red Harvest, Spenser.
  • Allan Pinkerton
    The man who put the "eye" in "private eye."

  • Charlie Siringo
    The original cowboy detective.

The Early Eyes
In the Beginning: Almost There

  • Sherlock Holmes by Sir Arthur Conan Doyle
    Like, I have to make a case here?

  • Horace Dorrington by Arthur Morrison
    He's one of the most vile P.I.s of all time, and he appeared over a century ago!

  • Sadipe Okukenu by John E. Bruce
    Not just the first black eye, but one of the very first eyes of all, predating even Hammett and Daly!

  • Jim Hanvey by Octavius Roy Cohen
    Hanvey was already detecting in the Saturday Evening Post a year before Three Gun Terry made his debut.

The Twenties
Let There Be Light: The Real Deal

The Thirties
The Pulps and Beyond

The Forties
Apres la guerre

The Fifties
Under the Hammer

The Sixties
Feel It

The Seventies
Everyone Into the Pool

The Eighties
The Renaissance

The eightiesare when I really became interested in private eye fiction, and I'll probably always have a weakness for the era. It was certainly an exciting time for the genre, particularly the series P.I. There were so many great series launched in the seventies that were just really hitting their stride about then. Pronzini, Parker, Block, Hansen and the like had already demonstrated there were plenty of new ways to use the genre, and in their wake (and perhaps at least partly inspired by them, or at least by Parker's commercial success) a whole bunch of new voices (Grafton, Paretsky, Mosley, Burke, et al) entered the genre in the early eighties. In retrospect, I can see that when the slew of non-pale males and other fresh voices began to pop up all over the genre, it was not so much a big shake-up as a logical progression to what had been going on in the seventies (and arguably, the sixties as well).

Of course, some of the other older writers (and older fans whose sole qualification for a P.I. was seemingly whether they could imagine Bogart playing them in a film or not) began to resent the success of Parker and some of these other uppity newcomers who were tinkering with the form. But the genre would probably be a quaint museum piece by now, appreciated only by collector geeks, or relegated to the men's action racks (over there by the skin mags), if it hadn't seen such a vigorous renewal and growth spurt in the late seventies/early eighties.

The Nineties
Sisters (and Everyone Else, It Seems) are Doing It For Themselves

The Oh-Ohs



| Home | Detectives A-L M-Z | Film | Radio | Television | Web Comics | Comics | FAQs |
|
Trivia | Authors | Hall of Fame | Mystery Links | Bibliography | Glossary | Search |
|
What's New: On The Site | On the Street | Non-Fiction
| Fiction | Staff | The P.I. Poll |

Remember, your comments, suggestions, corrections and contributions are always welcome.
At the tone, leave your name and number and I'll get back to you...