Mulligan and Garrity (The Gorilla)

Created by Ralph Spence
(1890-1940)

“Out go the lights—on go the thrills!
Shrieks! Yells! Roars! Screams! More Shrieks!
MULLIGAN, MULLIGAN,
WHERE THE HELL IS MULLIGAN?”
— lyrics from the musical

Ralph Spence’s 1925 play The Gorilla: A Musical Comedy, was a slight piece of silliness that intentionally lampooned the whole haunted house genre, so popular at the time. A killer known only as “The Gorilla” (Strangler of men—kidnapper of women!) is the prime suspect in the murder of a wealthy businessman whose daughter hires private detectives MULLIGAN and GARRITY, worrying that her boyfriend may be suspected of the crime.

The bumbling detectives investigate, and eventually most of the suspects end up chasing each other around a creepy old mansion full of trap doors, secret passages and the like until the murderer — a man in a gorilla suit — is apprehended.

Any doubts that this was anything but a parody are easily dispelled by the pay’s tagline “Out-bats ‘The Bat’! Out-cats ‘The Cat and the Canary’! Out-warns ‘The Last Warning’.”

Parody or not, the play lasted only fifteen performances on Broadway. But it fared considerably better in its subsequent run in Chicago, and went on to inspire several films.

The first version was silent and appeared only a few years after the curtains went down on Broadway. Mulligan was played by Fred Kelsey and Garrity by Keystone Cops vet Charles Murray, while the young suitor, Stevens,  was played by a very young Walter Pidgeon.

It’s all played out as scenery-chewing slapstick, making Spence’s already ridiculous play even more ridiculous, but audiences must have liked it, because it wouldn’t be the last adaptation. It was filmed again in 1930 and in 1939 (with the singin’ dancin’ comedy trio The Ritz Brothers).

But you couldn’t kill this thing with a stick. Parts of it were even regurgitated for a 1937 Warner Bros. flick called Sh! The Octopus, with the gorilla converted to an octopus.

Of course. Throw in some Scooby Snacks and it would be a perfect Scooby Doo episode.

PLAYS

• THE GORILLA: A MYSTERY COMEDY | Buy the script
  (1925, New York)
  Script by Ralph Spence
  Produced by Donald Gallaher and James W. Elliott’s
  Songs include “Mr. Mulligan and Mr. Garrity”
  Original cast:
  Clifford Dempsey as MULLIGAN
  and Frank McCormack as GARRITY
  With Frank Beaston, Joseph Guthrie, Stephen Maley, Harry Southard, George Spelvin, Robert Strange, Frederick Truesdale, Harry A. Ward, Betty Weston
  Chicago cast:
  Lon Hascall, James C. Marlowe, Elizabeth Carmichael, Curtis Cooksey, Edgar Macon; Wilbur Cox, Ralph Theodore, Carl Rose, Thomas Bell & Frederick Wallace
  There were only fifteen perfomances on Broadway, but the subsequent run in Chicago fared much better, running from May until September in 1925.

FILMS

• THE GORILLA
  (1927, First National Pictures)
  80 minutes
  Silent
  Based on characters created in The Gorilla: The Musical Comedy by Ralph Spence
  Screenplay by Alfred A. Cohn and Harry McArthur
  Directed by Alfred Santell
  Produced by Alfred Santell
  Starring Fred Kelsey as MULLIGAN
  and Charles Murray as GARRITY,] Also starring Walter Pidgeon, Brooks Benedict, Syd Crossley, Alice Day, Claude Gillingwater, Gaston Glass, Aggie Herring
• THE GORILLA
  (1930, Warner Brothers)
  Based on characters created in The Gorilla: The Musical Comedy by Ralph Spence
  Screenplay by Ralph Spence
  Adapted by B. Harrison Orkow and Herman RubyDirected by Bryan Foy
  Starring Joe Frisco as GARRITY
  and Harry Gribbon as MULLIGAN
  Also starring Lila Lee, Purnell Pratt, Edwin Maxwell, Roscoe Karns, William H. Philbrick
• SH! THE OCTOPUS
  (1937, Warner Brothers)
  54 minutes
  Based on The Gorilla: A Musical Comedy (1925 play) by Ralph Spence and Sh! The Octopus (1928 play) by Ralph Murphy and Donald Gallaher
  Screenplay by George Bricke
  Directed by William McGann
  Produced by Jack L. Warner
  Starring Hugh Herbert as KELLY
  and Allen Jenkins as DEMPSEY
  Also starring Marcia Ralston, John Eldredge, George Rosener
  Included here for thoroughness, although not a private eye film. Kelly and Dempsey are NYPD detectives, out of the 49th precinct. Possibly (from what I’ve been able to gather) the most headscratching and inept of all the films (which is saying something), with the haunted house replaced by a supposedly abandoned lighthouse, and the gorilla replaced by, yes, an octopus. Buy hey, it was only a dream, after all!
• THE GORILLA | Buy this DVD
  (1939, 20th Century Fox)
  Based on characters created in “The Gorilla” by Ralph Spence
  Screenplay by Rian James and Sid Silvers
  Directed by Allan Dwan
  Starring The Ritz Brothers, Bela Lugosi, Patsy Kelly
  Click here for more details.

Report respectfully submitted by Kevin Burton Smith, with a wave of the tentacles to Tim Beer.